Fat Prejudice and Obesity
Is obesity stigma preventing you from getting the care you need?
June 2012 — How do you see your doctor? Do you see a person interested and involved in your care? And how does your doctor see you? Does your doctor see you as a person with type 2 diabetes, or as an overweight or obese individual? If he or she does see you as overweight or obese, how does that viewpoint affect your care?
A provocative new article by Sharon Begley discusses the stigmatization of fat in our society. The article outlines a new study that demonstrates how patients' and doctors' views of one another can create problems in care for obese or overweight people with type 2 diabetes.
According to the article, physicians "often spend less time with an obese patient, and do not counsel them about a healthy lifestyle, perhaps believing it would fall on deaf ears." These negative attitudes from doctors and nurses can prevent obese patients from seeking treatment for diabetes, according to a study led by Elizabeth Teixeira of Drexel University College of Nursing and Health Professions.
"Patients are afraid of hearing, 'you're fat,' or 'just lose weight,' as if it were that easy," said Teixeira, a nurse practitioner specializing in diabetes. "I've had patients tell me they delay seeking care, even having their blood pressure or glucose checked, because they don't want to be lectured."
As if that isn't bad enough, the article also cites a 2010 study from Johns Hopkins University that found that the more overweight a patient, the more likely a doctor is to assume he or she is not taking medications as prescribed. Other studies have shown that this assumption may keep physicians from prescribing the necessary medications to these patients.
Clearly, this is a state of affairs that must be changed.
The first step may be to work on the widespread stigmatization of people who are overweight. Society focuses on individual responsibility for weight gain, making obesity seem like a result of laziness or a lack of discipline. In fact, contrary to the belief that losing weight is simply a matter of eating less and moving more, the prestigious Institute of Medicine has recently reported that the best way to stop the obesity epidemic is to change the eating environment. One way to fight obesity may be to limit the availability and marketing of calorie-dense food. We could also make lower calorie foods more generally available and provide more opportunities for exercise in schools and the community at large.
The second step is to start working to fight our society's prejudice against the obese. Studies have shown that children as young as three are already making assumptions about why people are fat and the "character flaws" that lead to weight gain. This means we need a concentrated re-education plan to make fat stigmatization as unacceptable as other types of prejudices.
The third step is to take responsibility as patients at an individual level. This means knowing that these prejudices exist, but refusing to take second-class care. Insist that your doctor evaluate you as carefully as other patients, and don't avoid getting needed tests. Denial only works until it doesn't.
The bottom line of this issue is simple: No matter what a person's size, they deserve equal respect. Medical professionals, who, frankly, should know better, should particularly observe this dictum.
It's past time to look at every patient as someone who deserves equal consideration and equal care. The very health of our nation depends upon it.
dLife's Viewpoints columnists are not all medical experts, but everyday people living with diabetes and sharing their personal experiences, most often at a set point in time. While their method of diabetes management may work for them, everyone is different. Please consult with your diabetes care team before acting on anything you read here to find out what will work best for you.
1 – Begley, Sharon. 2012. Insight: America's hatred of fat hurts obesity fight. Reuters. http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/05/11/us-obesity-stigma-idUSBRE84A0PA20120511 (Accessed 6/2012).
2 – Teixeira, Elizabeth. 2011. The effectiveness of community-based programs for obesity prevention and control. Patient Intelligence 3:63-72.
Grilled Veggie Wraps Citrus Raspberry Tartlets Apple Pear and Grape Salad Salsa Roja Three Pepper Dipping Oil Squash Ribbons with Garlic Lemon Sauce Southwestern Chicken Pasta Mixed Greens with Sun-Dried Tomato Vinaigrette Tomato Pizza Grilled Vegetable Platter
We all make choices every single day. Sometimes we make the right ones, sometimes we make the wrong ones. Hopefully, we weigh the consequences of the choices - hopefully we think of others even if the consequence for ourselves isn't all that bad. Hopefully, we measure our own selfish wants and desires and outcomes against the overall picture of the situation. Even if we think our actions are right, even if our actions might bring us happiness or good fortune, what will...