Drawbacks to Pump Therapy

By Gary Scheiner, MS CDE

Making an educated decision about pump therapy means that you should be aware of the potential drawbacks associated with its use.

  • Financial Cost — Insulin pumps and disposable pump supplies (infusion sets, cartridges/reservoirs, patch pumps/pump bodies) cost far more than conventional pens and syringes. However, insurance companies have come to realize that insulin pump use can result in better control and fewer health problems. As a result, most private and public insurance plans cover most or all of the cost of pumps and supplies.?
  • Adjustment Period — Just as it took some time to get your blood sugars regulated when you first started on insulin injections, it will take some time to get regulated on the pump. Expect at least a few weeks of "ups and downs" as you and your health team work together to establish proper doses.
  • Inconvenience — While insulin pump therapy does allow greater lifestyle flexibility, wearing the pump around the clock can be inconvenient at times. The pump must be worn while you sleep, work, and play in order to provide a continuous flow of "basal" insulin.  However, the compact size of the pump and "disconnect" mechanism make wearing the pump easier than it might seem.?
  • Technical Difficulties — As with any mechanical device, there are bound to be technical problems from time to time. Although today's pumps have an excellent reputation for safety and reliability, there remains the possibility of occasional infusion set clogs, computer glitches, and damage due to typical wear and tear. Every pump user must be prepared to switch back to injection therapy in the event of a pump malfunction.  Luckily, all pump manufacturers offer 24/7 customer support and can usually have replacement equipment delivered within 24 hours.
  • Skin Problems — One of the most common problems associated with insulin pump therapy involves skin irritation. Today's infusion sets feature hypo-allergenic adhesives that minimize skin irritation, but those with very sensitive skin may still experience itching, rashes, or inflammation. A variety of alternative tapes are available for those who need them. Skin infections are another potential problem, particularly for those with a history of staph infections.  In addition, lipodystrophy – damage to the fatty layer under the skin – can occur if infusion sites are overused and not rotated properly.?
  • Ketosis — Ketones are potentially harmful acids produced when cells are not able to burn sugar for energy, usually due to a deficiency of insulin. If not treated quickly, mild ketosis can turn into DKA (diabetic ketoacidosis), a life-threatening condition that requires emergency treatment at a hospital. Because there is no long-acting insulin with pump use, any interruption in insulin delivery (due to an infusion set problem, for example) for more than a few hours can lead to ketosis. Pump users must check their blood sugar level several times a day, and should test their blood or urine for ketones with any abnormally high blood glucose readings. The presence of ketones in the blood or urine usually means that the pump is not delivering insulin properly. All insulin pump users should be trained on how to respond to ketosis in order to prevent DKA.?
  • Sports — Wearing an insulin pump during high-impact, contact or water activities can present a challenge. Although most pumps are waterproof, some people feel uncomfortable or inhibited while wearing the pump in the water and choose to simply disconnect for short intervals. Some even feel uncomfortable about having the small infusion set on their skin when there is potential for impact. The ability to disconnect and re-connect has made pump use much more convenient during sports & exercise, but practical issues (such as sliding into home plate during a game of baseball) may still be a consideration.

Gary Scheiner is the 2014 AADE Diabetes Educator of the Year and author of "Think Like A Pancreas".  He has had type-1 diabetes since 1985, and offers diabetes management consulting services worldwide via his website, www.integrateddiabetes.com.

Last Modified Date: April 04, 2014

All content on dLife.com is created and reviewed in compliance with our editorial policy.

Sign up for FREE dLife Newsletters

dLife Membership is FREE! Get exclusive access, free recipes, newsletters, savings, and much more! FPO

Congratulations!
You are subscribed!
Congratulations!
You are subscribed!
Congratulations!
You are subscribed!
104 Views 0 comments
by Lindsey Guerin
After about a month off the Omnipod and using MDIs again, I’d adjusted to the details of the Lantus and Humalog dance. My skin wasn’t chronically itchy and sensitive. My pants didn’t irritate my pod site. And my blood sugars were surprisingly better controlled. I experienced consistently in range numbers compared to the variability of the Omnipod. Last month, the CDE said something that I know I’ve heard before but it hit a chord. Her own daughter was type 1 and switched between...